Manzanos Enterprises
Menu
Your Commission Plan Pays for the Wrong Sales: 6 Rules to Pay Salespeople for Profit, Not Revenue
← Вернуться к новостям

Your Commission Plan Pays for the Wrong Sales: 6 Rules to Pay Salespeople for Profit, Not Revenue

By Victor Fdez. de Manzanos · CEO & Owner, Manzanos Enterprises

In 2016 American regulators fined Wells Fargo $185 million after its employees opened roughly two million deposit and credit card accounts that customers had never asked for. The bank's internal slogan for cross-selling was "Eight is great": eight products per household. In 2020 Wells Fargo agreed to pay $3 billion to settle the criminal and civil investigations that followed. Nobody wrote a policy telling staff to open fake accounts. The sales targets and the pay attached to them did that on their own.

A commission plan is the most precise instruction you will ever give a sales team, and they will follow it to the letter, not to the spirit.

Most companies are nowhere near a scandal. Their problem is quieter and more expensive over time: a plan that pays on revenue in a business that lives on margin. The salesperson who discounts 15% to close before month end earns more than the one who held the price and walked away. The plan rewards the deal that hurts the company, every month, and nobody notices because revenue keeps going up.

November is when most companies set next year's sales plans. After more than a century of selling wine, homes, hospitality and services across a group with nine active businesses and more than 180 people, these are the six rules I apply before any commission plan is signed.

Rule 1: Pay on gross margin, not on revenue

Take two deals of $10,000 each. The first has a 35% gross margin, so it leaves $3,500 to pay for the business. The second was won with a heavy discount and a free extra, and leaves $1,200. On a 5% revenue commission, both pay the salesperson $500. On a 15% gross margin commission, the first pays $525 and the second pays $180.

When the commission follows the margin, the salesperson starts defending your price as if it were their own money, because now it is.

This does not require showing every cost to the sales team. It requires a margin figure per deal that the team trusts. In practice that means:

  • A standard cost per product set by finance, updated once or twice a year, not a moving number that sales can argue about every week.
  • Margin calculated on the invoice, after discounts, free goods, rebates and freight you paid for.
  • One rate applied to that margin, so anyone can check their own pay.

Paying on revenue still makes sense in a few cases: a single product line with fixed prices, or a launch where volume genuinely matters more than margin for a defined period. Write that period down and end it.

Rule 2: The commission is earned when the customer pays

A calculator on top of a printed sales chart, the arithmetic of a commission plan that pays on margin and on cash collected
A calculator on top of a printed sales chart, the arithmetic of a commission plan that pays on margin and on cash collected

A sale that is never collected is not a sale. It is a gift with an invoice attached. If commissions are paid at signature or at invoice, the salesperson is paid for the customer's promise while the company carries the risk.

Pay the commission on cash received, and claw it back if the goods come back or the invoice goes bad.

Two details make this work. First, tell the team the rule before the year starts, not after the first bad debt. Second, give sales a reason to care about who they sell to, which is exactly why I wrote about setting customer credit limits before a bad debt hits. A salesperson who loses their commission on a customer who never pays will start asking for references on their own.

Rule 3: A discount comes out of both pockets

Every sales team I have known has the same instinct at the end of a quarter: cut the price to close. Under a revenue plan, a 10% discount costs the salesperson 10% of their commission and costs the company far more, because the discount comes straight out of the margin.

If the commission is on margin, a discount automatically comes out of the salesperson's pocket and the company's at the same time, which is the only fair way to share it.

Add one more guardrail: a floor price below which no deal closes without written approval from someone who does not earn commission on it. When a competitor cuts prices, that floor is what keeps a nervous team from following them all the way down, a situation I covered in how to survive a price war without destroying your margin.

Rule 4: If they cannot calculate it on a napkin, it will not change behavior

Complex plans feel sophisticated in a spreadsheet. On the sales floor they produce two things: suspicion and arguments. If a salesperson cannot work out roughly what a deal will pay them before they quote it, the plan is not steering their decisions. It is just a payroll calculation they find out about later.

My rule is no more than three measures in any plan, and one of them should carry most of the money.

A workable structure for most private companies:

  • A base salary that covers a reasonable living, so nobody has to choose between a bad deal and paying rent.
  • A margin commission that carries most of the variable pay.
  • One strategic bonus, for example new accounts opened or a product line you are launching, with a clear target and a fixed amount.

Everything else, from activity metrics to customer satisfaction, belongs in the manager's review, not in the pay formula.

Rule 5: Do not cap the upside, audit the behavior

Owners often cap commissions because a single salesperson earning more than the general manager feels wrong. It is the wrong instinct. If the plan pays on margin and on cash, a record commission means record profit that has already been collected. Capping it tells your best people to stop selling in October and push the deals into January.

The real danger is not someone earning too much. It is someone earning it the wrong way.

The Wells Fargo case is the extreme example. A smaller one comes from Sears in 1992. California's Department of Consumer Affairs accused Sears Auto Centers of recommending unnecessary repairs, and the investigation pointed at quotas and commissions for service advisers. Sears settled, and its chairman Edward Brennan scrapped that commission system. In both cases the pay plan created exactly the behavior it rewarded.

The protection is not a cap. It is a short list of checks someone outside sales reviews every quarter:

  • Returns, cancellations and credit notes by salesperson.
  • Discount levels by salesperson against the team average.
  • Customer complaints and any account opened or changed without a clear customer request.

Rule 6: Change the plan once a year, in writing, after a dry run

Nothing destroys trust in a sales team faster than a plan that changes in the middle of the year because the owner thinks someone is earning too much. Even when the change is justified, the team hears one thing: the rules move when I win.

Run next year's plan on last year's real deals before you announce it, and you will find the surprises while they are still cheap.

The dry run answers three questions. What would each person have earned? Which deals would have paid more or less, and why? Does the total cost of sales pay stay within what the margin can afford? Then put the plan in a one-page written agreement, signed by each salesperson, with the effective date, the formula, the clawback rule and what happens when someone leaves with deals still unpaid.

This also connects with yesterday's lesson on promoting a top performer to manager: a good commission plan lets your best seller earn a great living without having to become a manager to get a raise.

Key Takeaways

  • A commission plan is an instruction. Salespeople follow it literally, so design it for the behavior you want, not the number you want.
  • Pay on gross margin, not revenue, so the team defends your price.
  • Pay when the customer pays, and claw back commission on returns and bad debts.
  • Make discounts cost both sides, with a floor price that needs approval from someone outside sales.
  • Keep it to three measures that anyone can calculate on a napkin.
  • Never cap the upside. Audit returns, discounts and complaints instead.
  • Change the plan once a year, in writing, after running it on last year's deals.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is commission based on sales or profit?

It can be either, and the choice decides what your team optimizes for. Revenue commissions reward volume, even at a low margin. Gross margin commissions reward profitable deals and discourage discounting, which is why they suit most businesses where prices are negotiated.

What is the formula for calculating commission?

The basic formula is the commission base multiplied by the commission rate. On a revenue plan the base is the invoice amount after discounts; on a margin plan it is the invoice amount minus the standard cost of what was sold. A 15% rate on a deal with $3,500 of gross margin pays $525.

How do I write a commission agreement?

Keep it to one or two pages and include the effective dates, the formula with a worked example, when commission is earned (at signature, invoice or cash received), the clawback rules for returns and bad debts, how disputes are resolved and what happens to unpaid commissions when someone leaves. Have each salesperson sign it, and check local employment law, because some US states regulate commission agreements and final pay.

How do salespeople get paid?

Most salespeople receive a base salary plus variable pay, usually commissions and sometimes a bonus for specific goals. The split depends on how much the salesperson influences the sale: the more the result depends on their own effort, the larger the variable share tends to be.

Should commissions be paid on invoice or when the customer pays?

Paying when the customer pays is safer for the company and better for behavior, because it makes the salesperson care about the customer's ability to pay. If the sales cycle makes that wait too long, pay part at invoice and the rest at collection, with a clear clawback.

Final Thought

A commission plan is one of the few documents that every salesperson reads closely, every month, with a calculator in hand. That makes it one of the most powerful management tools a company has, and one of the most dangerous when it is wrong. Pay for the margin you keep and the cash you collect, and the plan will do part of your management for you.

To see how a group founded in 1890 has built businesses in wine, real estate, hospitality and more, learn more about Manzanos Enterprises.

Building or scaling something interesting?

Let’s talk about how we can collaborate.

Talk to our team →

Будьте в курсе

Ежеквартальные обновления о группе, новых открытиях и избранные истории.