Manzanos Enterprises
Menu
Your Best Performer Will Probably Be a Worse Manager: 6 Rules Before You Promote Your Star
← Retour aux actualités

Your Best Performer Will Probably Be a Worse Manager: 6 Rules Before You Promote Your Star

By Victor Fdez. de Manzanos · CEO & Owner, Manzanos Enterprises

In 2019 the Quarterly Journal of Economics published a study that put a number on a mistake almost every growing company makes. Economists Alan Benson, Danielle Li and Kelly Shue looked at sales workers across more than a hundred US firms and found that companies promote the people who sell the most, even though top sellers turn out to be worse managers. Yale's summary of the research estimated that if those firms had promoted the people with the best management potential instead, their teams could have sold about 30% more.

That is the Peter Principle, first described as a joke in 1969 and now measured with data. And I recognize it, because I have made the same promotion more than once. You have a star who closes deals, fixes the hardest machine or knows every customer by name. A manager leaves. Promoting the star feels like a reward, a safe choice and a message to everyone else all at once.

Then, six months later, you have lost your best performer and gained a struggling manager, and both problems are yours.

Across a group that has grown since 1890 into nine active businesses and more than 180 people, I have learned that a promotion is a hiring decision for a different job. These are the six rules I now apply before I move someone from doing the work to running the people who do it.

Rule 1: Write down the manager job before you look at the candidates

Most promotion decisions start with a name. Someone asks "who should replace Maria?" and the conversation is about people from the first minute. The better order is the opposite: describe the job first, then look for the person.

A manager is paid for the output of other people, so the job description has to be written around other people. Before any name is on the table, I want three things on one page:

  • What the team must deliver in the next 12 months, in numbers.
  • What the manager will actually spend time on: hiring, coaching, scheduling, resolving conflict, reporting, saying no.
  • What the manager must stop doing: usually the very work that made the candidate excellent.

Google learned this the hard way. Its Project Oxygen research, which began in 2008, ranked the behaviors of its best managers, and technical expertise came last of the eight on the original list. Coaching, communication and caring about the team's success came first. If a company full of engineers found that, a winery or a workshop will find it too.

Rule 2: Look for evidence of management behavior, not management ambition

Wanting the title is not a qualification. The question is whether the person already does, informally, some of what a manager does.

The best predictor of a good manager is someone who is already making the people around them better, without being asked. Look for it in specific places:

  • Who do new hires go to with questions, and do they come back better prepared?
  • Who stays late to help a colleague hit a deadline, not just their own?
  • Who gives hard feedback calmly, and to whom do people listen?
  • Who shares credit in meetings?

Gallup's research on managers estimates that only about one in ten people have high natural talent for managing. That means the person with the best numbers is probably not that one in ten, simply by the odds. Ask the team, quietly, who they would follow. Their answer is often different from the sales ranking, and it is usually right.

A manager standing beside a team member at his desk, coaching him through a call, the daily work that a promotion actually changes
A manager standing beside a team member at his desk, coaching him through a call, the daily work that a promotion actually changes

Rule 3: Build a second ladder so the star does not need the title to grow

Many top performers ask for a management job for one reason: it is the only way up. More money, more status, a better title. If management is the only door, your best specialists will walk through it whether they want to manage or not.

Give excellence a path that does not require managing anyone. In practice that means:

  • Senior specialist titles with real pay bands, such as senior account executive, master technician or head winemaker for a single estate.
  • Bigger responsibilities without direct reports: the most important customers, the hardest projects, the training of new hires.
  • Variable pay that rewards the work itself, so a star seller can out-earn a sales manager.

Large companies have done this for decades. IBM has named IBM Fellows, its top technical position, since the early 1960s, precisely so that its best engineers do not have to become managers to be recognized. A family business can do the same at a smaller scale. If you want to keep key people with a stake in the result, our guide to phantom equity for key managers explains one way to do it without giving away shares.

Rule 4: Test before you promote, with a real assignment and a real end date

A promotion is hard to reverse. Demoting someone is painful for them and visible to everyone. So reduce the risk before the decision, not after.

Give the candidate a piece of the manager job for 60 to 90 days, with clear goals and an agreed review date. Examples that work:

  • Running the onboarding of two new hires.
  • Leading a small project team across departments.
  • Covering for the current manager during a holiday or a busy season.
  • Owning one recurring meeting, with the decisions and follow-ups that come with it.

At the end, review results with the candidate and with the people they led. Some discover they love it. Others discover they hate it, and that is a good outcome, because you learned it without a demotion. Tell everyone in advance that the test can end either way, so nobody loses face.

Rule 5: Train the new manager before the first bad week, not after

The common pattern is to promote someone on Friday and expect them to manage on Monday. They have never run a performance review, handled a resignation or told a friend that their work is not good enough. Then the first hard week arrives.

The first 90 days decide whether a new manager succeeds, and almost nobody plans them. A simple plan covers:

  • Days 1 to 30: one-on-one meetings with every team member, learning the numbers, no big changes.
  • Days 31 to 60: set expectations in writing, agree priorities with their own boss, fix one visible problem.
  • Days 61 to 90: first formal feedback conversations, first decisions on hiring or roles.

Pair the new manager with an experienced one who is not their boss, someone they can call before a difficult conversation. And be explicit about the hardest change: they are no longer the best performer on the team, they are responsible for everyone's performance. Many new managers keep doing the old job because it is where they feel competent. The team then has no manager, and the manager is exhausted. If your leadership meetings are still full of updates instead of decisions, our rules on making the weekly leadership meeting decide things help set the right rhythm early.

Rule 6: Keep an honest way back, and measure the team, not the manager

Sometimes, despite everything, the promotion does not work. The worst response is to wait two years hoping it will improve while good people leave the team.

Agree at the time of the promotion that there is a respectable path back to the specialist role if either side wants it. Put it in writing. Keep their old pay band or a better one. Present the move as a choice about where the person creates the most value, which is the truth.

To know whether it is working, measure the team rather than the manager's own activity:

  • Team results against the plan.
  • Voluntary turnover and absences in the team.
  • How many team members improved or were promoted.
  • What the team says in an anonymous check every six months.

Gallup has estimated that managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement across business units. If the team is getting worse, the promotion is not working, however hard the new manager is trying.

Key Takeaways

  • A promotion to manager is a hiring decision for a different job, and past performance in the old job is weak evidence for the new one.
  • Write the manager job description before you discuss names, including what the new manager must stop doing.
  • Look for people who already make others better, and ask the team who they would follow.
  • Create a specialist career ladder so top performers can grow in pay and status without managing anyone.
  • Test with a 60 to 90 day assignment that has clear goals and an agreed end date.
  • Plan the first 90 days and give every new manager an experienced peer to call.
  • Agree a respectable way back in advance and judge the promotion by the team's results.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Peter Principle?

The Peter Principle is the idea that people in an organization tend to be promoted until they reach a job they cannot do well. It was described by Laurence J. Peter in 1969. A 2019 study by Benson, Li and Shue found evidence of it among sales workers: firms promoted the best sellers, who then performed worse as managers.

Should you promote your best salesperson to sales manager?

Only if they also show management behavior, such as coaching others and sharing credit, and only after a trial period. Selling and managing are different skills. Many companies keep their best seller selling, with higher pay and a senior title, and promote someone with stronger coaching ability.

Why do top performers often fail as managers?

Because the job changes completely. A top performer is rewarded for personal output, while a manager is rewarded for the output of others. Many new managers keep doing their old work because it feels familiar, avoid difficult conversations with former peers, and never receive training for the new role.

What is the 30-60-90 day plan for a new manager?

It is a simple structure for the first three months. The first 30 days are for listening and learning the numbers, the next 30 for setting expectations and fixing one visible problem, and the final 30 for the first real decisions on feedback, hiring and roles.

How do you turn down a promotion gracefully?

Thank the person who offered it, explain that you believe you create more value in your current role, and propose a way to grow in it, such as larger accounts or training others. A good company will respect the answer, especially if it has a specialist career path.

Final Thought

In a family business, a promotion is also a story the whole team reads. Promoting the star tells people that results matter. Promoting the right person, and giving the star another way to grow, tells them something better: that the company is thinking about the next ten years, not just the next quarter.

To learn how a group founded in 1890 has built teams across wine, real estate, hospitality and more, read more about Manzanos Enterprises.

Building or scaling something interesting?

Let’s talk about how we can collaborate.

Talk to our team →

Restez informé

Mises à jour trimestrielles sur le groupe, nouvelles inaugurations et histoires sélectionnées.